The Age-Old Debate: Book vs. Screen

The phrase "the book was better" has become a cultural cliché, and for good reason. Books offer vivid worlds, complex characters, and nuanced plots that are often lost in the transition to the screen. However, when beloved literature is poorly adapted, it leaves fans feeling not only disappointed but sometimes outright betrayed.

Evaluating Adaptations

A recent study by Aura Print analyzed some of the most egregious book-to-screen adaptations by comparing the Goodreads rating for the book with the IMDb rating of its film or television adaptation. Check the original article here.

Good Adaptations: Rare but Possible

Not all adaptations fall short. In fact, there have been adaptations that surpassed their paperback counterparts. For example, the series "Normal People", based on the novel by Sally Rooney, offers an exceptional viewing experience that adds new layers to the original story.

The Biggest Fails: Unpacking Disappointment

1. Netflix’s "Uglies"

The Netflix adaptation of Scott Westerfeld's 2005 dystopian novel "Uglies" received a dismal 16% on Rotten Tomatoes. Despite a promising premise, critics noted,

"It’s what’s on the inside that counts, but unfortunately 'Uglies' doesn’t have much going on in there, either."

2. Game of Thrones: Season Eight

While not a direct book adaptation, this conclusion to George R.R. Martin's epic series left fans with a sense of anticlimax, as major plotlines were rushed or discarded entirely.

3. "A Wrinkle in Time"

Madeleine L'Engle's intricate universe was transformed into a visually stunning but narratively weak film, straying too far from the intelligence and complexity of the original material.

4. "The Girl on the Train"

Paula Hawkins' gripping thriller lost much of its psychological depth in its cinematic version, leaving audiences unengaged and perplexed by the protagonist's journey.

The Bright Side: Merchandise for the Discerning Book Lover

Fans looking to express their literary love despite disappointing adaptations can explore bookish merchandise at Liam and Lore. With a wide range of products, you’ll find unique gifts and collectibles that celebrate the essence of the written word.